There just might be a competing product. I received a flyer from Ascend =
today announcing their Radius and billing software. I have not had the =
time to check it out but there is a free 30 day evaluation. I assume =
the product is directed towards the Ascend market.
Regards,
David M. Lay
dlay@amtelgrp.com
-----Original Message-----
From: Jeffrey Betts [SMTP:jbetts@ccaccess.net]
Sent: Monday, March 10, 1997 8:19 PM
To: emerald@emerald.iea.com
Subject: Re: Emerald management
Greg=20
You have some legitamate concerns but
I don't think any of them will be solved anytime
soon. I have come to the conclusion that emerald
will allways be a work in progress. I came to this
conclusion two months ago. It has functioned
for me within the expactations I have had for it
very well. Now if we could get the credit card=20
funtions to work it would be great :) Anyway=20
Dale has done a great job if you consider all
the things he has to do I think just dealing with
this list is a job in itself. So untill someone comes
up with a competing product I don't think there
will be any way Computech will put the type of
manpower you want on this product.Competition
seems to wake people up at times.
Jeff Betts
Jbetts@ccaccess.net
----------
> From: Greg Boehnlein <damin@seka.nacs.net>
> To: emerald@emerald.iea.com
> Cc: Brian Coburn <brianc@iea.com>
> Subject: Re: Emerald management
> Date: Monday, March 10, 1997 6:27 PM
>=20
> On Mon, 10 Mar 1997, Marc Elbirt wrote:
>=20
> > Dale:
> >
> > [deleted]
> >=20
> > This message is also directed to Computech's management. Although
Emerald
> > is visionary and its utility unquestionable, unless you dedicate =
more
> > resources to it and to your customers, we will grow continously more
> > unhappy. Please do something; my business depends on you.
>=20
> I would just like to say that there are many points in the last =
message
> that I agree with. It is great that we can talk to Dale on the list. =
It
is
> wonderful that we can call him and get questions answered. It is nice
that
> the software has a vision and someone that knows it intimately.
>=20
> What happens if Dale becomes incapacitated? (Stress induced holiday =
for
> example..) Who will manage the source code? Who will answer the =
technical
> support questions? Who will address the fixing of the "Creeping
Featurism"
> bugs that Emerald is a victim of?
>=20
> In a private mail to Dale, I addressed these very same issues. I feel
that
> he is overworked, and spread far to thin between supporting the =
products
> and writing the code for it.
>=20
> As an example, let me point out the specific problems that I see with
> Emerald...
>=20
> 1. Lack of documentation. I can't really hand anything out to my Staff =
to
> usr as a Reference on a Day to Day operational basis. The
documentation
> that exists is out of date, wrong or just plain incomplete. When we
> purchase a product such as Emerald, for the price we pay for it, we
> expect to have some sort of documentation to RTFM. I can't tell my
> staff to "E-mail to Dale". Heck, we paid for a Support Contract and
> I'm not quite sure what that gives us, but I'd sure love to KNOW!
Heck,
> even Microsoft software comes with a manual!
>=20
> 2. Program frequently crashes and apparently has no Crash Recovery =
built
> into it. For example, try entering incomplete RADIUS information =
under
> the services Tab (Framed-Route w/ Nothing) and then hit the Save
> button. You will get a very undignified "Error" dialog and then the
> program disappears. There are only a couple of fields that I am =
aware
> of that provide Field Based Error checks.
>=20
> 3. The program is difficult to setup and extremely un-intuitive. While
> using an SQL backend is fast and flexible, it means nothing if we
spend
> 2-3 months learning how Emerald works (without any documentation). =
It
> does not provide any advantages if it requires someone w/ 2 years =
of
> MS-SQL experience to administer and fix.
>=20
> 4. The program is in perpetual beta testing. There is no "ship date" =
that
> I am aware of, nor a reccomended "stable" release.
> =20
> These are just some of the larger concerns that I am pointing out, =
having
> purchased Emerald. In my letter to Dale, I expressly stated that I do =
not
> see Computech or IEA being able to support this program in the long =
run
> without some sort of Support / Maintenance / Documentation / =
Programming
> staff and strategies. Please take this as a strong strong suggestion =
from
your customers that we would like to see more in these areas.
>=20
> The concept is great. Dale's work up to this point has been as good as
can
> be expected from someone with the responsibilities that he has. There =
is
> major potential here for much future business... If you can work out =
the
> issues that I have addressed here.
>=20
> I have a client looking at the possibility of using Emerald to
> authenticate a college worth of students. They are in a "wait and see"
> holding pattern until we can show them that the product and support =
are
on
> the level that they expect. As a consultant, I have to choose the best
> software for the application, and while I believe Emerald has the
> potential, I am not quite convinced of the other areas yet.
>=20
> Sincerely,
> Greg Boehnlein
>=20
> --
> President of New Age Consulting Service, Inc. Cleveland Ohio
> SLIP/PPP/Unix Shell 28.8k / ISDN / Leased Line
> http://www.nacs.net info@nacs.net (216)-524-8414
>=20
>=20
> ----------------------------------------------------------
> Emerald Mailing List listserver@emerald.iea.com
----------------------------------------------------------
Emerald Mailing List listserver@emerald.iea.com
------ =_NextPart_000_01BC2D93.94BBA860
Content-Type: application/ms-tnef
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64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------ =_NextPart_000_01BC2D93.94BBA860--